Shopping> Kauffman's Homemade Fruit Butters & Schnitz
We make our All Natural Fruit Butters right here on the farm. These products get their rich, delicious flavor from our old-fashioned process of cooking the fruit in fruit juices, retaining the natural sugars and fiber of the fruit. We take care to make all of our Apple, Peach, Pear and Pumpkin Butters "just right".

Keith in Georgia wrote us about it:
I'm sure you know this but just wanted to say that Kauffman's Apple Butter is THE best I've ever tasted. LOVE the wholesomeness, texture, and of course the taste that you've perfected -- and I consider myself an apple butter connoisseur so I should know! (have tried dozens of different ones). And my whole family agrees with me! We always buy a large supply when we go on vaca in Madeira Beach, Florida and visit the Amish Ice Cream and Foods store there. But now I just realized I can buy it online too. Anyway, just wanted to express our sincere gratitude for your exceptional family business. All the best to you.
Showing 1 - 14 of 14
This, our "maroon label" apple butter, is the most popular no-sugar-added Fruit Butter choice of all here at Kauffman's Fruit Farm! It is authentic like no other apple butter. You and yours will enjoy the all natural, full flavor that is produced when cinnamon is blended with healthful fresh apples and sweet apple cider.
This is an improvement on our Plain Apple Butter, since it has added sweetener, BUT the sweetener is naturally-produced honey instead of added sugar. This recipe is just the ticket for folks with diabetes.
Homemade Fruit Butter Gift Pack
22095
Your choice of any combination of ten styles of our famous, homemade Apple, Peach, and Pumpkin Butters, half pint jars. Packed in an attractive gift box that is custom-cut for four half-pint jars.
Take our best-selling Pumpkin Butter, make it without adding sugar... and you have a dieting-friendly breakfast food just like that! Imagine pumpkin pie as a bread spread, and you have the idea. As with all our Fruit Butters, this is homemade right here at our Bird-in-Hand orchard.
A bit unusual, perhaps, but it's a best seller! Imagine pumpkin pie as a bread spread, and you have the idea. As with all our Fruit Butters, this is homemade right here at our Bird-in-Hand orchard.
Mix 'n Match Fruit Butters & Jams, Half Pints
22508
With this easy-to-order pack, you can customize a box of half-pint fruit butter and jams with any of Kauffman's 3 dozen+ scrumptious flavors. Pricing will change as you add or subtract jars. Minimum purchase is 2 jars.
Mix 'n Match Fruit Butters & Jams, Pints
22509
With this easy-to-order pack, you can customize a box of pint fruit butter and jams with any of Kauffman's 3 dozen+ scrumptious flavors. Pricing will change as you add or subtract jars. Minimum purchase is 2 jars.
Showing 1 - 14 of 14
Blog
Read our Blog!